Attorney-General to law enforcement: Comply strictly with suspects' constitutional rights
Attorney-General to law enforcement: Comply strictly with suspects' constitutional rights
Featured

Attorney-General to law enforcement: Comply strictly with suspects' constitutional rights

The Attorney-General and Minister for Justice, Dr Dominic Akuritinga Ayine, has directed law enforcement agencies to comply strictly with constitutional and legal requirements in conducting criminal investigations to protect the fundamental rights of suspects.

The directive prohibits unlawful detention, torture, coercion, searches without legal authority and the use of improperly obtained statements as evidence in criminal proceedings. Signed by the Attorney-General, it took effect on November 2, 2026, and is to be reviewed after 12 months.

It requires investigating officers to inform arrested persons of the reasons for their arrest and their right to a lawyer, while ensuring that suspects are brought before a court within 48 hours of their arrest or detention.

The directive was addressed to the Inspector-General of Police, the Director-General of the Criminal Investigations Department (CID), the Executive Director of the Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO), the Director-General of the National Investigations Bureau (NIB), the Narcotics Control Commission and other public institutions with powers to investigate criminal offences.

Dr Ayine said the Office of the Attorney-General had observed recurring practices that fell short of constitutional standards, including detention beyond 48 hours without production before a court, arrests to recover civil debts, coerced or improperly recorded statements and searches without lawful authority. He noted that such practices undermined effective prosecution, exposed the Republic to compensation claims and eroded public confidence in the criminal justice system.

Arrest and detention

Under the directive, an arrest must be made on a warrant or without a warrant only where the Criminal and Other Offences (Procedure) Act, 1960 (Act 30), or another law expressly permits it. It further requires officers to inform arrested persons immediately, in a language they understand, of the reasons for their arrest and their right to a lawyer of their choice. Where a suspect cannot afford legal representation, the officer must inform them of the services of the Legal Aid Commission.


The directive clarifies that the 48-hour period within which an arrested person must be brought before a court begins from the moment their liberty is first restrained, and not from the time the arrest is entered in the police diary. It states that before the expiry of the period, the officer in charge must either release the suspect, with or without enquiry bail, or bring the person before a court.

“Detention beyond that period without a court order is unlawful and shall not be justified by weekends, public holidays, transfer between stations or incomplete investigations,” it said.

The directive also prohibits unacknowledged or incommunicado detention and requires the officer in charge to inform a relative or a person nominated by the suspect of the arrest and place of detention without delay, unless the suspect objects.

Treatment of suspects

On the treatment of suspects, the directive prohibits torture, beating, threats, sleep or food deprivation, stripping, humiliation and threats against relatives. It states that no exceptional circumstances or orders from superior officers could justify such treatment.

It further requires every detainee to have access to adequate food, water and sanitation, as well as medical attention where necessary. An injured or unwell detainee must be examined by a medical practitioner without delay, with the examination recorded. The directive also requires female suspects to be searched only by female officers and detained separately from male detainees.

It adds that any officer who witnesses or learns of the ill-treatment of a suspect must report it immediately to the head of the agency, who must ensure that the matter is investigated independently of the officers involved.

Statements and searches

On interrogations and statements, the directive requires investigating officers to caution suspects before interviews in a language they understand, informing them that they are not obliged to say anything and that anything they say may be used in evidence. It states that confessions are admissible only when made voluntarily and prohibits officers from obtaining statements through threats, promises, cruel or inhuman conditions or physical suffering.

Where a suspect makes a statement while under arrest, restriction or detention, it must be made in the presence of an independent witness who understands the language spoken by the suspect. The witness must also be able to read and understand the language in which the statement is written. The directive further provides that a suspect who requests a lawyer must be given a reasonable opportunity to consult one before and during an interview.

On searches, it requires officers to obtain a court-issued warrant before searching premises, except where a law expressly authorises a warrantless search. Where a warrantless search is conducted, the investigating officer must record the legal authority relied on and the reasons a warrant could not first be obtained. It also requires searches, where practicable, to be conducted in the presence of the occupant or an adult representative and an independent witness.

Bail and release

The directive makes it clear that liberty should be the rule and detention the exception. It requires suspects to be released on enquiry bail where investigations can continue without them being held in custody. It also prohibits excessive or unattainable sureties, cash deposits and the retention of title documents as conditions for bail.

“Bail is free,” the directive said, warning officers against demanding or accepting payments, gifts or favours for the grant of bail. Every grant, refusal or condition of enquiry bail must be recorded with reasons, while suspects refused bail must be brought before a court within the constitutionally prescribed 48-hour period.


Accountability

To strengthen accountability, the Attorney-General said heads of law enforcement agencies were to submit quarterly compliance reports to his office. The reports must include the number of persons arrested, released on enquiry bail and brought before court, as well as instances of detention beyond 48 hours and allegations of ill-treatment, unlawful searches and coerced statements.

He also said agencies were required to incorporate the directive into their standing orders, training curricula and induction programmes for investigators within 90 days after it takes effect.

The directive warns that evidence obtained in breach of the Constitution or the law may be excluded at trial and could cause a prosecution to fail. It further says the Office of the Attorney-General may decline to prosecute or discontinue a case where serious breaches have tainted the evidence.

Where a breach is established, the head of the agency concerned is required to take disciplinary action and report the measures taken to the Attorney-General.